Revised comments creative review
@omadrid - Thanks for the work on comments. Please see below a list of minor changes required before releasing the new version.
-
The left side of nested replies should align with the parent as indicated in the design here -> https://www.sketch.com/s/506ab6d3-9bd6-4537-becc-1b74c285d9c9/a/oeybmn - Note how the left side of the nest reply input aligns perfectly with the left-side of the up-vote icon -
The left side of a comment should align with the left side of the Comments
header above -
The comment count should reflect only the top-level count, and not any nested replied. In the below case, the total comment count is 1
-
When a user clicks Reply
, the relative reply input should focus automatically - rather than have the user click twice to start replying. -
The spacing between up-vote, down-vote and reply should be increased to match the original design. -
The nested 'add your reply' inputs should only appear when the user clicks 'reply'. If the user simply clicks 'View x replies' there is no need to show the relative reply input. See design here https://www.sketch.com/s/506ab6d3-9bd6-4537-becc-1b74c285d9c9/a/oeybmn compared to implementation. -
After reply has been clicked, and the reply input is displayed, the reply text the user originally clicked on should disappear. -
Click clicking 'reply', the reply input should appear directly under where the reply button was. Not also there is no need to show the replies, when the user simply wants to add a reply -
Reduce the size of the comment ellipsis ever so slightly so it better aligns with the design -
A side note, but it looks like line breaks are stripped out from replies. Not sure if this is a frontend of backend concern, but thought I'd mention it. -
The up-vote, down-vote icons etc should use the secondary text colour -
My bad, but can we reinstate the 'view x comments' label for feed view posts please? It feels better with