'Branch already exists' error when selecting existing branch in file edit view

When editing an existing file and choosing an existing branch as the 'Target branch', an error occurs when attempting to commit: 'Branch already exists'

Screen_Shot_2017-05-16_at_10.26.54_AM

Error on commit

Screen_Shot_2017-05-16_at_10.26.48_AM

cc/ @smcgivern