Follow-up from "Add proposal for user access with GitLab credentials"

The following discussion from !671 (merged) should be addressed:


I want to discuss the GitLab Core side a bit more, but it doesn't need to block the merging of the premium side. I want to merge that now so we can start working on the frontend access.

My concern with access_as:impersonate as the GitLab Core option is twofold:

  • A custom User and Groups allows manual emulation of a large part of access_as:user. The main thing missing would be the user's role (developer, maintainer etc).
  • Having to set up access_as adds friction
Edited by Hordur Freyr Yngvason